The last time that I saw a Rajinikanth movie within the first one week of its release was way back in the early 1990s - the name of the film was Veera. I got the tickets from a Rajini fan club through a friend of mine. Needless to say, I was surrounded by Rajinikanth fans in the hall - each dancing and whistling whenever their hero danced or enacted one of his "style acts". The fans got into a delirium whenever he spouted his one-liners - punch lines as they call these in the Tamil film industry. The experience was truly magical. I am not a big Rajinikanth fan but I still made my way out of the cinema hall truly impressed with his ability to entertain the masses.
My recent vacation to Madurai gave me another opportunity to experience the Rajinikanth magic in the movie Sivaji - again within a week of its release. After seeing all the hype in the media about how tickets were advanced booked and that the going rate in the black market was to the tune of Rs.900/ticket, I did not imagine that I would be able to see this movie. But when a friend of mine, a die-hard Rajinikanth fan, offered to get me tickets to the movie, I was pleasantly surprised. I grabbed at it and within an hour some six or seven of us made our way to the theater in the heart of Marudai city.
To my surprise, I found that they were still selling tickets to the movie - Rs. 70 tickets to the balcony. The man at the counter also said that they will start selling the Rs. 50 tickets (the front bench tickets) after the balcony tickets were sold out. We had our tickets with us anyway and we made our way in and found seats that gave us the best view of the screen.
Very soon we realized that the cinema hall was not going to be thronging with people. The balcony was probably 90% full while the front bench seats were empty. When we looked down from the balcony we could see the entire hall below was empty - not a seat taken. And this was within the first week of the movie's release, on a Saturday for the Matinee show. To say that I was surprised and taken aback would be an understatement.
Now let us move on to the movie - Sivaji. It started off well with Rajinikanth being taken to prison - a very interesting but unusual start to a Rajinikanth movie. But the flash back tells you what actually happened to the NRI returned Software System Architect who wanted to invest his Rs.200 crores that he earned in the US to provide free education and healthcare to all. He faces stiff resistance from his chief rival Adiseshan. In addition, he faces the red-tapism in the government.
So far so good! But suddenly the focus shifts to Rajini finding his lady love - he prefers a girl dipped in Tamil culture. Then the movie starts dragging - the next 90 minutes is devoted to the tomfoolery of the hero wooing his lady love - the actress with dead-pan expressions Shriya - along with his sidekick Vivek. The sequences were utterly foolish, ridiculous and the attempted humour was completely lost on me. This 90 minutes of wooing included occasional switches back to the story line to show the kind of difficulties that Sivaji faces in realizing his dream. It appeared that the main storyline was sidetracked. Added to this is the disappointing music from AR Rahman - the songs were bland and it was difficult to figure out which language the lyrics were in. The background music was loud and a cacophony. The intended humour with Solomon Papaiya and "Patti Mandram" Raja were insipid and the reference to Papaiya's daughters (who were pitch dark in skin colour) as Shriya's alternative choice to Sivaji was in very poor taste. This was included in a film where Shriya rejection of Rajinikanth because of his skin colour was being ridiculed.
The second half was a shade better than the first half but the illogical sequences continued. The villain, who is powerful enough to change the government, pays up Rs. 100 crore to Sivaji to avoid his files reaching the Income Tax office. I mean - a villain so powerful, can he not get his files back from the IT office even if Sivaji hands them over to them? Would he be a fool to pay up such a huge amount to his arch rival? The other sequences where Sivaji uses force to make people heed and provide him with information was another unbelievable sequence. But credit to Shankar for trying to expose the ills of the society in the form of black money, hawala transactions, official nepotism etc.
The rest of movie where Sivaji bounces back, thanks to the Hawala transactions, and then gets killed by the Adiseshan only to return as another person named MG Ravichandran aka MGR, and the climax of the movie were as banal as it can get.
When the movie ended after a good three hours I headed my way out with a headache and not feeling one bit entertained. The movie was so disappointing that I found even die-hard Rajinikanth fans walking out during the song sequences for a smoke instead of jumping, whistling and dancing during the song sequences. I realized that the buzz around the movie was nothing but a media hype and that the movie was definitely a big flop despite whatever the trade pundits claim. A Rajinikanth movie running to empty cinema halls in the first week of its release is unprecedented and I could understand why the movie had failed after seeing the film - this was a film which had neither a strong storyline nor a powerful character for Rajinikanth. It cannot match the magic of his earlier films like Baasha, Veera, Annamalai, Padaiyappa where Rajinikanth had excellent author backed roles and the movies also had a strong story line with an excellent script.
To sum up - Sivaji was a total disaster.